You see it on a shelf tag or wine list: "93 points." But what does that number tell you, and should it influence what you order?

Quick answers
Do wine points matter? A score can help you discover a wine, especially if you're unfamiliar with the region or producer. But it isn't a guarantee that you'll like the bottle.
What does a wine score mean? It's one critic's or publication's judgment of a particular wine and vintage, summed up on a 100-point scale.
Is a 90-point wine good? On Wine Spectator's scale, 90–94 means "outstanding." Other publications use different bands.
Why don't all wines have a score? Many are never submitted or selected for review. No score doesn't mean low quality.
So what's a wine score?
Most wine scores are a critic's assessment of a particular wine and vintage. The familiar 100-point scale is a way to sum up that judgment. It isn't a percentage or an objective measurement.
The descriptions vary by publication. Here's how Wine Spectator defines its scores:
Score | Wine Spectator's description |
|---|---|
95–100 | Classic |
90–94 | Outstanding |
85–89 | Very good |
80–84 | Good |
75–79 | Mediocre |
50–74 | Not recommended |
Those are Wine Spectator's categories, not a universal standard. Decanter, for example, uses different score bands. There are other reviewers as well, like Jeb Dunnuck and James Suckling, and they each score a little differently.
Why don't all wines have scores?
A score usually begins with a bottle reaching a critic or publication. Some wines are submitted voluntarily by the producer, importer, or representative. Others are selected for a tasting or competition. Publications can't taste every wine being made, and their review schedules and submission rules differ.
That can make it harder for a small winery to get noticed. A producer may have less time, money, distribution, or access to the people who submit samples. A wine may also be made in a small quantity or come from a region that receives less coverage. Or the winery may not have much wine to allocate, or may not even want the attention.
A lack of a score doesn't tell you whether the wine is good or not. It tells you that it may not have crossed a reviewer's desk. There's simply too much wine for anyone to review it all: James Suckling's team says it rated about 45,000 wines in 2025 alone.
How does a wine get reviewed?
The process depends on the publication. Wine Spectator asks producers or representatives to contact the appropriate office before sending samples. Wine Enthusiast accepts submissions through its ratings platform and says submitted wines are tasted blind. Other publications and competitions have their own policies, fees, and submission rules.
A review also doesn't always mean a feature in a magazine. Wine Enthusiast says reviews appear online, while only selected reviews appear in print.
What is the critic looking for?
Critics assess a wine's quality and character. Some also consider how they expect it to develop with age. The tasting note gives you details the number leaves out: fruit, acidity, tannin, body, oak, and overall style.
The tasting method matters, too. Wine Spectator says its editors taste blind in groups of similar wines, without knowing the producer or price. Decanter describes blind panel tastings where judges score individually before discussing the wines. Methods differ, so it helps to know whose score you're reading.
Will a higher score taste better to you?
There's no guarantee. A critic might give a high score to a bold, full-bodied Cabernet, while you prefer a lighter Pinot Noir. The number reflects the critic's judgment of the wine. It doesn't tell you whether that style suits your palate.
When I first started tasting wine, I did a whole tour of Argentina searching for wines rated 95 points and up. I quickly realized some of the ones I enjoyed most came from small wineries without any numbers behind them.
I recommend reading the tasting note before getting attached to the score. If you like fresh, bright wines, descriptions such as "crisp," "lively," or "red fruit" may be more useful than a high score on a wine described as rich and powerful. Scores can place a wine among its peers, but they don't explain its style on their own.
Scores are a clue, not the answer
At Tannin Bar, we love discovering wines from small and sometimes little-known producers, whether they have a score beside them or not. A rating can be a helpful clue. It's not the only reason to give a bottle a try.
Tell us what you like, and we'll help you find a glass to explore. Take a look at our menus too.




